patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Unfortunately, Herman Cain't

Is Georgia-born Herman Cain ready for the grueling spotlight of a presidential campaign?

 

Don't get me wrong, I like Herman Cain and even voted for him in the 2004 Republican primary when he challenged then-Congressmen Johnny Isakson and Mac Collins for the GOP nomination for an open U.S. Senate seat. Cain finished an impressive second place and almost forced Isakson into a runoff. However, based upon what I've heard from the Herminator the past few days, I have serious doubts that he has what it takes to survive the media gantlet standing between him and the GOP presidential nomination.

Cain has a lot going for him and is creating some positive buzz among likely Republican voters, both here in Georgia and nationally. Herman had a successful corporate career with Pillsbury and Godfather's Pizza and is the former chairman of the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City. Many locals know him as the former host of a talk show on WSB radio. He's good-looking, enthusiastic, motivational and knows how to dish out enough conservative red meat to keep the Tea Party crowd coming back for more.

On the campaign trail Cain likes to play up the fact that he's never held elected office, and with an electorate turned off with both Democrats and Republicans in Congress, his lack of experience is seen by many as a plus. America likes underdogs and outsiders, and Cain fits both bills. However, that inexperience also brings with it a huge risk.

Presidential politics is not just a national version of a congressional race. It's a faster, tougher and more unforgiving endeavor, and the highway of American history is littered with presidential candidate roadkill. You get few second chances as recently evidenced when both liberal and conservative pundits wrote off the campaign of former House Speaker Newt Gingrich after a couple of missteps shortly after he announced the official launch of his campaign.

I was pulling for Cain during the South Carolina GOP debate a couple of weeks ago but found myself shouting at the television all evening in frustration. Yes, Cain garnered a lot of support that night, and Frank Luntz's focus group tilted overwhelmingly to Cain after watching his performance. While he hit the right notes at times that night with his regular campaign stump one-liners, the lack of depth to some of his answers was concerning. He had several opportunities to hit home runs but instead only squeezed out some base hits. 

A great example of the weaknesses I see in Cain's preparation came this week on Fox News Sunday, where except for the generosity of host Chris Wallace, Cain's candidacy could have been dealt a severe setback. For the past week Cain has hammered President Obama on foreign policy, especially concerning Obama's speech outlining demands concerning Israel and the creation of a Palestinian state.

When a candidate focuses in on a specific issue and goes after a sitting president as hard as Cain did Obama, he'd better be prepared for some probing questions about the topic. Wallace tossed Cain some general softballs on what his policy would be concerning Israel and the Middle East, which he handled with some of his standard one-liners. When pressed for more depth, Cain more or less repeated what he had already said.

Then Wallace asked Cain what his policy would be concerning "right of return." Cain was like a deer caught in headlights and had no clue what Wallace was even talking about. Cain muttered, "Right of return? Right of return?" I saw the wheels turning in Chris Wallace's brain. He could have destroyed Cain for his lack of knowledge on an issue central to the whole Israel/Palestinian conflict but instead rephrased the question with a tremendous amount of detail so as to lead Cain to an answer. Even with the help, Cain stumbled badly with his response.

In the early days of the campaign, most journalists are likely to be somewhat forgiving as candidates occasionally trip themselves up. However, we'll quickly get to that point in the contest when the true vetting begins and the weak will be cut to shreds. As a black conservative Republican hoping to challenge the nation's first black president, Cain makes for an interesting storyline. There are some in the media who will treat him gently, hoping he can gain traction so that when they do take him down, he'll land with a thunderous thud, disenfranchising the Tea Party gang and also blacks who are considering voting Republican this time.

Is there still time for Cain to turn things around? Absolutely, but the window is small. He needs a lot of professional media coaching to be able to play at the presidential level. I hope he gets it and makes the Republican nominating process a memorable one. 

Follow me on Twitter @chuckshiflett and also check out my statewide columns at The Backroom Report.

About this column: A conservative with a touch of libertarianism, Chuck Shiflett shares his views. Related Topics: 2012 presidential election, Election, Herman Cain, Israel, President, President Obama, Republican, chuck shiflett, georgian, and presidential candidate
Does Herman Cain have what it takes to win the presidency? If not, which Republican does? Tell us in the comments.

jim crow

3:24 pm on Tuesday, May 24, 2011

"As a black conservative Republican hoping to challenge the nation's first black president, Cain makes for an interesting storyline"

This is coded racism at its finest. Chuck Shiflett says the story is interesting because Cain and Obama are black. Why does there race make it interesting. Maybe because Chuck Shilett is so racist he only sees black politicians as an interesting novelty since they can not possibly be intelligent enough to be legitimate contenders. He starts off his article with "dont get me wrong, I like Herman Cain". Well you probably like the "interesting" monkeys in the zoo too, yet you would write articles about how they can not handle the media scrutiny and are not smart enough to be president. Yet you wistfully do acknowledge that two monkeys, oops you meant black men, battling it out would be "interesting". Welcome to the world of coded racist journalism. If Chuck took a lie detector test and was asked one question- "Chuck do you believe that the black race is inferior to the other races intellectually?" he would answer No! and he would fail every time. That is because Chuck does not hate blacks, he likes them, he just thinks that the black race is a mentally inferior race of sub humans. But do not worry, at least he thinks we are "interesting".

Reply
Comment_arrow

Todd Maxwell

5:09 pm on Tuesday, May 24, 2011

I'll tell you why race makes it interesting: because people like you get into such a tizzy about it every time race is brought up. You and people like you are like John Nash in your ability to find "racist codes" where there are none. So convinced are you of conservative hatred for blacks that when you are confronted with evidence to the contrary, you have to painfully mangle the facts to make them fit your malformed worldview.

Don't pretend you feel a shred of indignation over anything said here about Herman Cain. I can tell by what you write they way you think, and I know you hold no love for Cain. If he should get the GOP nod, it won't cause you to rethink anything. You'll just concoct some far-fetched reason why Cain isn't really black, or you'll fabricate a means by which conservatives can like him while remaining racist.

The fact is, you don't know the first thing about conservatives, and for that alone you hate them, making up other reasons along the way.

Comment_arrow

John

12:14 am on Wednesday, May 25, 2011

So if liking a black candidate makes a white person a racist, what doesn't? I guess I'm a racist too then because I'm white and I also like Cain. Well you've certainly changed my mind on the subject. I hope a white candidate wins this time because obviously "you people" are still carrying around too much racial baggage to handle the job. What a shame. I would have really enjoyed a good "monkey" fight - as you put it. Maybe when people like you overcome your hyper-racial sensitivty we can try this whole black, negro, colored, Afro, African-american (whatever) experiment again in another 50 years or so. You're clearly weren't ready yet. See you at the zoo.

Comment_arrow

Bill Thrasher

12:00 pm on Sunday, October 23, 2011

Where in the world is the coded racism embedded in Chuck's article. Or must you be a black person in order to see it? Herman Cain was woefully lacking in his preparation for questions about foreign policy, and Chris Wallace did give him a pass.

Comment_arrow

John

10:31 am on Thursday, October 27, 2011

Wow! You mean black people really DO come from monkeys! I always wondered about that too. I guess you'd be the one to know. Why aren't bananas their favorite food then instead watermelons? Makes a lot of sense though, the way they're always swinging on basketball hoops. That's probably why I don't run into many black people whenever I go to the zoo - they're in the cages! It's so obvious! Just wait till I tell kids! Thanks Jim Crow

Todd Maxwell

5:31 pm on Tuesday, May 24, 2011

I think you are reading too much into the "right of return" thing. I think Cain had a temporary mental black-out on the term. (Oh gee, I hope that's not "coded racism.") Clearly, he had thoughts on the topic once he got back on track.

I also think it is a bit much to expect more in-depth answers from the format the SC GOP debate took. How many people were up there? In any case, the response times were very short, and I felt that Cain's answers were above par for the field he was in. Perhaps because he is more familiar to you, having had the chance to vote for him before, you were disappointed that you didn't hear more that was new to you. But for most of America, the GOP debate was an introduction to the contenders.

I think the window is still plenty open. These announcements are coming out very early compared to only a few cycles ago. I feel like there is lots of time for voters to get to know their candidates well before voting.

Reply

J.M. Prince

7:30 pm on Tuesday, May 24, 2011

An otherwise attractive guy for the GOP primary, but also deeply confused on many things, besides the 40 + year debate on the 'right of return'. He's constantly getting the Constitution confused with the Declaration of Independence in his rhetoric too. He was fortunate in that Chris Wallace was more than gentle with him during the interview. And no, normally the media is not that friendly either. I guess Herman might have waited a few days and listened to Netanyahu's speech before Congress today. Now there's a man who knows how to use rhetoric well.
JMP

Reply

jim crow

7:49 pm on Tuesday, May 24, 2011

todd maxwell,
I am a black conservative. I do support Herman Cain, so you are way off on your appraisal of what I think. I am sick and tired of hearing liberals and conservatives say they think Herman Cain isnt legitimate and he cannot win. Their reasoning is garbage and at the bottom of the garbage lies the inherent belief that many whites have that the black race is genetically inferior to the white race in terms of intellectual capacity. This racist rhetoric comes from books like the bell curve, websites like stormfront.com, and the liberal and conservative media. Liberals attack Herman Cain often because they fear they will lose their precious race card and often just because many of them feel he will be twice as inferior as Obama(because he is twice as black). Now not only does Cain have to deal with attacks from the Liberal media, he is being attacked by conservative elites like Karl Rove and many others who say that he has no chance of winning because they know everything and to hell with what those pesky voters think anyway.

Reply

Mike Hickam

9:38 pm on Tuesday, May 24, 2011

Mr. Crow, I don't want to start an argument here but I gotta tell ya, not all white conservatives are racist. I have to take offense to your comment that many whites feel the way you say. I also think Mr. Cain is one of the most intelligent men I have ever seen or heard and I am definitely white. I do think he is going to have a hard time because of not having any political background but that's why I like the man so much. BTW, I would like to say that I think I am the first person in Bartow County to have a Herman Cain for President sticker on my truck. Something that I am proud of because a lot of people, of different races and genders, are asking me who Mr. Cain is. It is my pleasure to tell them. Keep this in mind Mr. Crow, there's more of us(voters) then there are of them (media). Put the word out and don't worry about the media. You and I and the voters can take care of that come Nov 2012.

Reply

Chuck Shiflett

11:41 pm on Tuesday, May 24, 2011

Jim, your comments aren't worth replying to. You have either deliberately or through ignorance distorted everything in my column. It isn't me that finds the black vs. black angle interesting ... it is America's media always looking for an angle to exploit. As I stated in the article I voted for Herman in 2004... and I would vote for him again if he were a candidate for congress or U.S. Senate. The point is that he is not ready for prime time for a presidential race. He lacks in depth knowledge on many issues, especially foreign affairs. As one who has trained candidates for state legislature, congress, and U.S. Senate, I can tell you from experience that the media will eat Cain alive once they begin to get serious. Chris Wallace gave him a pass. He won't be that lucky in a few weeks/months. The real racists are those who cry racism whenever a white person criticizes a black candidate. This has nothing to do with race... Cain is just one of many of all races who have dabbled with a presidential run this year but aren't yet thoroughly prepared. So Jim, please reread my column... slowly if you need to do... and try to absorb what I actually wrote.

Reply

Todd Maxwell

12:18 am on Wednesday, May 25, 2011

Perhaps Mr. Crow (if that is his real name) would be kind enough to enlighten us as to what other "racist code words" ought to be avoided. Thanks to him, I can add "interesting" to the list that already includes "articulate," "intelligent," "qualified," and “appealing,” all of which I used to think were compliments. Then there are some not-so-nice words, like “mediocre,” “inexperienced,” or “arrogant” which I’ve only lately learned all trace their origins to the antebellum south.

Besides those, I am stumped by some supposed code words, like "professor," "one term," "freedom," "tax cuts," and “celebrity.” In fact, it has recently been pointed out to me that “African American” is code for “black,” and thus racist. There is no word for the sensation of a spring coming loose in my head that accompanied that revelation.

Last, I can think of a handful that make some sense, but only because you can see what’s being twisted, like "welfare," “states’ rights,” "food stamps," and “community organizer.” Heck, just mentioning that the president plays basketball apparently serves no purpose but to remind people that the man is black.

But I’m sure that list is incomplete, so I am soliciting Mr. Crow’s help. Oh, and by the way, you can have “uppity.” I’ve come to accept that word as racist, even though it was routinely used in my family to describe some distant aunt who married rich.

Reply

J.M. Prince

2:49 am on Wednesday, May 25, 2011

In other shocking news Herman is currently doing quite well in the very early polls (more than a few #2s), and Hines Ward just won 'Dancing with the Stars'. So add 'twinkle toes' to the list too.
JMP

Reply

Herman Cain 2012

11:20 pm on Thursday, May 26, 2011

Herman Cain is a man of honor, integrity, and moral character. As a former President and CEO of Godfather’s Pizza, Mr. Cain proved himself a man capable of turning around a failing company, on the verge of bankruptcy, and returning it to profitability. His 3 point problem plan (1. Work on the right problem, 2. Ask the right questions, 3. Remove barriers to success), which he used as CEO, was proven to work, as the results speak for themselves. As President, his 5 point economic plan (1. Eliminate capital gains tax, 2. Eliminate tax on repatriated profits, 3. Reduce the corporate tax rate from 35% to 25%, 4. Issue a year long payroll tax holiday on both employers and employees of 6.2%, 5. Implement the Fair Tax) will spur economic growth not seen in over a generation.

Mr. Herman Cain is an unwavering supporter of Israel, and his problem solving ideas will be a boon for our foreign policy. A clear, concise and well drawn out plan will put an end to the quagmire in Afghanistan and Iraq, which we so desperately need as a nation.

Reply

String Bean

2:01 pm on Friday, May 27, 2011

2012, I think most folks who pay attention really like Herman and he has had a sucessful business career. However Shiflet is right - I've seen him stumble several times when asked basic questions about government or foreign policy. Personally I'd like to see him as the VP, but then we'd open up a whole can of worms that Republicans put the black man in the VP slot while Democrats put one in the top slot.

Reply

SUGERRAY888

6:04 pm on Saturday, October 22, 2011

WAKE UP EVERYBODY !!!!!!
THE GUY IS NOT QUALIFIED TO BE PRESIDENT !!!!!!
ENOUGH SAID !!!!!!

Reply

Bill Thrasher

2:09 pm on Sunday, October 23, 2011

Herman Cain is indeed a man of honor, integrity and moral fiber. He just needs to be better prepared to answer legitimate questions about matters that he will have to deal with if elected President. This is far less about being critical of the man than of openly strategizing with him to put him over the top

Reply

Bill Thrasher

2:12 pm on Sunday, October 23, 2011

Hey Chuck. If you remember, that grueling vetting process never materialized when Obama was running

Reply

Larry Welsh

1:50 am on Wednesday, October 26, 2011

Herman Cain is without doubt the most capable and qualified candidate that the Republican Party has to offer for 2012.

Reply

Leave a comment